Publish & Prosper
Where publishing, technology, and marketing collide. Brought to you by Lulu.com.
Publish & Prosper
Exploring the Hybrid Publishing Model
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this episode, Matt & Lauren explore the middle ground between self-publishing and traditional publishing. Dive in to discuss:
💡 How hybrid publishing has evolved to better support authors and creators
🤔 How to decide if hybrid publishing is the right solution for you
🚩 Red flags to avoid when researching hybrid publishers
If you’re exploring your publishing options, this episode is for you!
Dive Deeper
💡 Explore These Resources
- Lulu’s Partners Page
- Jane Friedman’s Key Book Publishing Paths
- See Paul Millerd’s The Pathless Path Deluxe Hardcover Edition
💡 Listen to These Episodes
- Ep #36 | The Indie Author’s Guide to Self-Publishing vs. Traditional Publishing
- Ep #127 | What’s the Difference Between Offset and Digital Printing?
- Ep #115 | Hiring the Best Freelancers for Your Book
💡 Read These Blog Posts
- The Publishing Journey: Traditional Publishing vs. Self-Publishing
- How to Spot and Avoid Fake Self-Publishing Sites
💡 Watch These Videos
- How to Know if a Publisher is Right for You
- How to Build Your Publishing Dream Team
- Publish Your Purpose Press x Lulu Webinar | Which Publishing Path is Right for You?
💀 Can’t wait for our next episode? Check out our Resources page for links to our blog, our YouTube channel, and more.
💀 Find us on Facebook, Instagram, and LinkedIn at luludotcom!
💀 Email us at podcast@lulu.com
💀 Sign up for our mailing list.
Matt: Welcome to Publish & Prosper.
Lauren: Sure is.
Matt: I feel like every time we sit down and talk, it's in a different...
Lauren: Arrangement?
Matt: Arrangement. I was going to say format, but not format. Arrangement.
Lauren: It's a...
Matt: We're still figuring this out.
Lauren: Yeah. Well, Rome wasn't built in a day.
Matt: Okay. I haven't heard that in a long time, but it's very applicable.
Lauren: I rode Spaceship Earth last week and, and –
Matt: Okay.
Lauren: – enjoyed the discussion of Rome.
Matt: Alright.
Lauren: Briefly.
Matt: So that's where it comes from. Got it.
[0:54] – Episode Topic Intro
Matt: We're not talking about our current arrangement today. Today we're talking about hybrid publishing.
Lauren: Yes we are.
Matt: And mainly we're going to talk about the differences between hybrid publishing and some of the other options that people already know about, but really helping to sort of define what it is, how to spot the red flags. All that good stuff.
Lauren: Yeah.
Matt: We're on the periphery or the edges of hybrid publishing as a self-publishing, print-on-demand fulfillment platform. A lot of hybrid publishers actually use us to get their stuff printed or out to market. So we're somewhat relative to that space, to a degree. And we've dealt with a lot of hybrid publishing companies. So I think we have a pretty good amount of knowledge to share.
Lauren: I think –
Matt: How do you feel about that?
Lauren: I, so I actually think – I agree with you. And I think that a lot of times when it comes down to like, the different publishing paths, and we're talking about the different paths to publishing, we default to self-publishing and traditional publishing.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: And hybrid publishing is the middle road between those two.
Matt: Yup.
Lauren: But I actually think that hybrid publishing and self-publishing have a lot of overlap in, in how they're useful to each other. Like you just said, there are plenty of hybrid publishers that use Lulu as their fulfillment solution as part of that process.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: I also think that they have a shared history in terms of both of them have carried a stigma against them in the publishing industry as a whole. Sometimes justified, sometimes not. And that they're both alternatives to the traditional publishing method. Like, I don't think that there is as much overlap between hybrid and traditional as there is overlap between hybrid and self-publishing.
Matt: Yeah. I mean, it certainly depends on who you're using as a hybrid publisher, but I agree with you on that spectrum. Hybrid is a little more to the self-publishing side than the, the traditional side, but nonetheless. It still incorporates some of the elements of traditional publishing. Although not many these days, but.
Lauren: Incorporates it, yes. But I think that I think like hybrid publishing and self-publishing can be used in tandem with each other. But I don't think that hybrid publishing and traditional publishing could be used – Like hybrid and traditional you would choose either or, whereas hybrid and self-publishing you, you could use pieces from both of them together.
Matt: Yeah, possibly.
Lauren: Yeah.
Matt: I don't know the full mechanics of that.
Lauren: Yeah.
Matt: Certainly there's some traditional publishing companies that own hybrid publishing companies.
Lauren: That’s true.
Matt: Or use that as a way to farm up. But yeah, nonetheless, I agree. I think that... and actually – well, we'll get into it. So today we're going to talk about basically five things. We're going to talk about what exactly is hybrid publishing. We'll give you somewhat of a brief history of it. We're going to talk about how it's evolved over the years, especially like the last three to five years. Let's say five years. Whether or not it works for you and what you're trying to accomplish with your book or your project. And then lastly, we'll talk about what some of the red flags are for hybrid publishers, versus what makes a reputable hybrid publisher. So those five things, we’ll keep it easy, we'll keep it tight, and we'll try to just keep moving.
[4:31] – Defining Hybrid Publishing
Matt: So yeah, I mean. You've talked about how there's a blending of self-publishing and traditional publishing to create this hybrid publishing model. But essentially what a hybrid publishing model really is, is an author or creator out front is going to pay for the costs of that book to be produced. Typically, hybrid publishing companies offer like packages, right? At different price points. Many of them are bespoke, so, you know, they'll sit down with you and they'll figure out what you want and they'll generate a price that way. But, you know, at the end of the day, the author is paying for that book to be produced. And it typically includes, you know, editing and design. It can include, you know, ghostwriting if that's needed. Although you start to cross into what we call a vanity press, and we'll get to that in a minute with, with ghostwriting. And so, you know, these hybrid publishers will offer different levels or degrees of editing and design work. Some of them already have built-in relationships with distribution channels, so they can handle that for you in the way that a traditional publisher would. Some also will literally want to see your manuscript. Or a pitch, right? Or a treatment –
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: – before they'll actually take you as a client. Some hybrid publishing companies, are very protective of their reputation and their brand in that way. Although many are not.
Lauren: Which – And we will talk more about this, as we get into talking about the history of them versus like how they're viewed and how they operate today. But I do think that that's actually probably one of the big distinctions between some of the more disreputable hybrid publishers of the past versus the successful ones of today. Is that, putting that emphasis on being selective with who they choose to work with and not just working with anybody.
Matt: Maybe.
Lauren: But I do think that is an important... Like, that's important to understand in the distinction of these, like, hybrid publishing is very similar to the traditional publishing in, in the services that they provide. You are, you are going to get some kind of a service package that will include –
Matt: You're gonna have a team –
Lauren: Yes. Yeah.
Matt: – that's working on your book, yeah.
Lauren: You're not doing it alone. And it's not something that you have to put this team together. Like self-publishing –
Matt: That’s right.
Lauren: You can have a team, but you would have to assemble that team on your own. Hybrid publishing you are you are going to be working with a company that will provide some, some or all of the services necessary to bring your book to market.
Matt: That’s right.
Lauren: Including possibly the sales and distribution element of that, maybe some marketing. Maybe it's just the formatting and editing, something like that. But unlike traditional publishing, the barriers to entry are fewer. It's, it's not always gated in the sense of quality control. Or you have to pitch your book or put together, what's the word? When you haven't – a treatment.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: But the other barrier to entry there is that you're paying for it. Traditional publishing, you know.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: It's much harder to get into, but you do not have to pay out of pocket for the services that the publisher is providing for you.
Matt: That’s right. Yeah. I think it's... that model fits really well, though, for what we're seeing today in the market for creators, for entrepreneurs, for even brands and businesses and even authors. The ability to, to pay and have a team of people that are dedicated to, you know, creating a really good book for you, and not having to do all that yourself. It's no different than if you're going to do, like, a kitchen remodel at your home. You can either pay a general contractor, and they're going to manage everything for you, and you're going to pay one price. Or you can find the flooring guy and you can find a tile lady, and you can find somebody that's going to handle, you know, some of the electrical and then the plumbing, and you can do all those things yourself. Which sounds like a huge pain in the ass to me. So yeah, hybrid publishers serve a very specific function, for sure. And if you have the money, it's worth it. Because it's less time you're spending doing some of those things. Or managing a bunch of disparate, you know, entities who are doing your editing and then your design and, you know, some of that other stuff. So I think hybrid publishing is a great model. There's a lot of different things there that you have to, to understand. And hopefully that's, that's what we'll clear up. But yeah it's, it's a mix of the two, and it is what it is.
Lauren: I think that's a very actually important thing for us to establish at the beginning. This is not in any way going to be anti-hybrid publishing.
Matt: No.
Lauren: Like I think we are both on the same page about if it is the right model for you. It's a great, it's a great path to take. And we're just trying to lay out what you need to know about, about it in general –
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: – and whether or not, like, how to figure out whether or not it is the right path for you.
Matt: I think if you find the right hybrid publisher, and you have the money, hands down it's the best way to go.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: Period.
[10:14] – The History and Stigma of Hybrid Publishing
Matt: Before self-publishing technology was readily available. You know, something you could just do online whenever you wanted, before Lulu. Vanity presses and and hybrid publishing was kind of what you were limited to if you weren't, if you weren't picked up by a traditional publisher. Vanity presses, how they differ, is literally in their name. Although for the longest time, people would call hybrid publishing vanity publishing. There was no real distinction for a lot of people. They didn't really understand the difference.
Lauren: I mean, even – we were talking about this before we started this episode and I have used vanity presses and, and hybrid publishing interchangeably for most of my career. Which has taken place largely in the publishing industry. So I – and Matt –
Matt: That's fair though. I think until you've worked or truly sort of immersed yourself in the world of self-publishing and really understand hybrid publishing versus what a vanity press is, I think that's the mistake everybody makes. And I think for the longest time, the industry was just okay with that.
Lauren: Yeah.
Matt: And I think even hybrid publishers were just kind of relegated to that. And they just quietly went on about their business. But, you know, a really good hybrid publishing company is not a vanity press at all. There's so many really good hybrid publishing companies that nobody's ever heard of. But yet every day they crank out really good books and they make a really nice profit doing it. It doesn't make them a vanity press at all. A vanity press is typically a form of hybrid publishing. It is a publishing company, right, where you're going to pay a pretty ungodly sum of money to them. More often than not they're going to ghostwrite that book for you. Although you may, you know, hand them your manuscript, but they'll make some, some updates to it. But typically vanity press, you're also paying for the book to be written for you. And then it usually carries some sort of branding along with it that you see as leverage in the market. A lot of people love to, to, you know, publish through things like, you know, Forbes Books or Forbes Publishing. That's a, essentially a vanity press. You're gonna pay a boatload of cash. They can ghostwrite it for you, or you can write it and they'll edit it and do all the things. But ultimately, what you're paying for is the vanity of that book. It's gonna say Forbes Publishing on it. It's gonna end up in a few airport bookstores, because they have some distribution relationship that would allow for that. And I'm not saying that it's not worth the money. Right? Like, in some instances it's very much worth the money, to certain people, to do that. To pay 150,000 or more for your book to be done and published as a Forbes book and end up on bookshelves and airports and some things. There are scenarios where that's really helpful. You know?
Lauren: Yeah I think – I mean, as, as so many things are that we talk about, including this episode itself, it always comes down to what your goals for your book –
Matt: Motivation. Yeah, absolutely.
Lauren: If, if your goal, if your number one goal for writing and publishing a book is clout, and clout in a very specific industry, or with a very specific group of people that the clout would come from Forbes Publishing being the name on your, your book’s spine –
Matt: Or many others.
Lauren: – or whatever it is.
Matt: Yeah, that's the one that came into my head.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: But yeah –
Lauren: Yeah. You know –
Matt: – we're not picking on them.
Lauren: No no no.
Matt: But.
Lauren: No shade. No shade to Forbes at all. But, but right. There, there is a time and place where that is the, the fastest means to achieving your goal.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: But it is gonna come with a heavy price tag.
Matt: So – Yeah, so again, the difference between vanity and hybrid really boils down to goals and motivation. It's typically there's, there's definitely usually a pretty big difference in cost, for sure. Oftentimes there is some ghostwriting involved. And then ultimately, you know, the the deciding factor is often what is the brand that's associated with it. So again, we threw out Forbes because that's one of the, the more popular ones people know. But there's, there's quite a few of them. And, you know, quite frankly, there's a lot of top level brands. They'll just license their name to a vanity publishing company to use to attract customers, and then they get a cut of that. So. That's a whole nother thing. But if you hear the term vanity press, it's not always a bad thing. It's just a different style of hybrid publishing. And it's probably not one that most of our listeners are ever gonna go after. Standard hybrid publishing really is probably the better model for most people.
Lauren: Yeah.
Matt: But again. So, you know, hybrid publishing is there because, you know, there was a time where self-publishing wasn't readily available. It wasn't as easy as it is now. And, you know, to get books printed, it wasn't always as easy as it is now either. You know? In many cases, print-on-demand as a model or digital printing, you know, as a method, weren't readily accessible to people. Sure if you had a print facility that was just down the road from your house, maybe you could walk in there and get them to print some copies for you. But, it wasn't like it was now, you know, fifteen, twenty years ago.
Lauren: Right.
Matt: So that's really how hybrid publishing was able to kind of come about and start making a name for itself in the publishing industry.
Lauren: Yeah. Yeah.
Matt: You know?
Lauren: And I do think that the, the history before that of vanity presses and the hybrid publishers that were more like, you're going to pay an arm and a leg to get two, ten, five thousand copies of your book printed. And then it's, it's up to you, you're on your own, good luck kid. I think that is where a lot of the negative stigma comes from in like the modern perception of it. And that's where a lot of, a lot of hybrid publishers today are fighting back against – not fighting against that, because they're not. But they have a little bit, or they had, I think, a little bit of an uphill battle –
Matt: Yeah. That's right. An uphill battle.
Lauren: In the modern industry.
Matt: They had some headwinds they had to fight –
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: – for sure. And to this day they still do. You're right.
Lauren: Yeah.
Matt: Because whether they were a vanity press or a hybrid publisher or even a self-publishing company, there's plenty of those out there right now.
Lauren: Yep.
Matt: Predatory behavior exists in all of them. Bad actors exist in all of those spaces. There's always going to be... and AI has made it even easier.
Lauren: Yep.
Matt: Like, we see so many fake, terrible self-publishing companies, hybrid publishing companies, vanity presses, you name it. But it's always going to be there. You know, that predatory behavior is something that – and that's one of the red flags we'll talk about. But that is the stigma that they've had for the longest time. You're right. It's, you know, the 80/20 rule. 20% of them were bad actors. They gave them all a bad name. You know, the other 80%. And the other 80% have been fighting those, those headwinds. You know, I think it's gotten much better now. And I think hybrid publishing itself has done a good job to, to kind of polish up their, their name and their model. And there's really a lot of great ones out there now. So. Yeah.
Lauren: Yeah.
Matt: I think we'll finish off kind of the history of, of, hybrid publishing and... just with the fun fact you had listed in the outline.
Lauren: Yeah. We wouldn't be here right now without the...
Matt: A bad –
Lauren: A bad actor.
Matt: Yup, that's right.
Lauren: A bad actor –
Matt: Or a bad experience.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: A bad experience with hybrid publishing, because that is why Lulu was founded.
Matt: That’s right.
Lauren: So we've definitely talked about that story before, but.
Matt: Yeah. Yeah we have.
Lauren: The TL;DR is that Bob Young tried to bring his book to market and had a lousy experience with a vanity press, probably.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: And said this should be easier, this should not be so difficult or so inaccessible for people. I'm going to figure out a way to make this possible for for people to do without going through all of the trials and tribulations that I did.
Matt: That’s right.
Lauren: And that’s how Lulu was born.
Matt: That's right. Yeah.
[18:35] – The Modern Hybrid Publishing Model
Matt: Okay. So how, how have the hybrid publishing companies evolved? How have they gotten to a place where they've been able to shake a lot of those stigmas and really create a better place for themselves in the publishing ecosystem? I think one of the, the first ways and, and the smartest things they've done is a lot of them really chose to start focusing on very specific niches.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: Or niches.
Lauren: No it's okay. You can say it.
Matt: Okay. I'm gonna, I'm gonna say niches.
Lauren: I’ll allow it.
Matt: I was going to keep going with that, but we haven't done that in a while. I'm going to leave it alone.
Lauren: Okay.
Matt: But yeah. So, you know, there's a lot of really good hybrid publishers out there, and they've gotten to that level because they have focused specifically on certain things. Whether it's, you know, nonfiction business books. Or, you know, fiction and, and they stick within the realm of fantasy and science fiction or... You know, there are vanity publishers that really like to focus on technology and, and certain other categories of nonfiction business books. There's some that focus specifically on academic. So the idea that they're focusing on specific niches, I think has really helped them sort of define themselves as authorities and or purveyors of really good quality work.
Lauren: Yeah. It allows them to really narrow focus and, and specialize in something. And I think that is... cause I agree, I think that is one of the main reasons that hybrid publishers have found more success. Is that not trying to just, anybody who wants to bring a book to market, we can help you, doesn't matter. Because so many of the things that make hybrid publishing an attractive solution, like having the services provided or having people that can help you with the editing and formatting... I don't care how good of an editor you are. Somebody who specializes in editing high fantasy novels is not going to edit a nonfiction how to guide the same way.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: Doesn't mean that they won't do a good job at both, but those are two very different things.
Matt: And as somebody who's creating that content, you're going to want somebody that specializes in editing the content that you're creating.
Lauren: Right.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: Right. And even when it comes to like, you know, we have relationships with specific distributors or we have relationships with specific influencers that will help market and promote your book –
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: – once that time comes. It's a lot easier to do that when you specialize in a specific genre or industry or whatever. So for sure, I think, I think that's a huge one.
Matt: Yeah. And I think that carries into the next thing, you know. What's helped them evolve was putting more focus on those services.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: Instead of, you know, what people perceived as empty promises that their book was going to be successful or sell 5,000 copies or whatever that might be. You know, for the longest time, I think hybrid publishing and vanity presses, that was their, you know, their hook. Was like, we'll make sure you're a bestseller. And more often than not, they really couldn't control that, especially when the authors were in charge of buying their own copies of their books or whatever. So by putting more focus on those services and the value that that drove for the creator or the author. I think that also helped help these companies evolve to, to something that they are today versus what they were viewed as ten, fifteen, twenty, thirty years ago.
Lauren: Yeah. Which I think is also not just a, a specialist thing or a specialization thing, but also a direct result of the technology that has evolved, because even for – even the, the best intentioned, well-meaning hybrid publishers of the past, when there wasn't the option of digital printing or print-on-demand, they had to charge people for the print run –
Matt: Yup.
Lauren: – the bulk print run of their book when offset printing was the only option.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: Then they had to charge upfront for that and then all the services on top of that. So now that there is the possibility of these hybrid publishers saying like you don't have to pay for print copies upfront, all you're paying for is the services that we're providing.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: And then we'll use print-on-demand to fill or to fulfill your print orders for your book, that lowers –
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: – that upfront cost. Or gives them the opportunity to lower that upfront cost, if they choose not to that's up to them.
Matt: I think lastly, one of the big areas that I think has really drawn more people towards them too, is they've become more flexible and creative with the way that rights, royalties, and profits are handled. Many hybrid publishers, especially some of the most reputable ones, they don't retain any rights to your content. In many cases, the royalty split is much more in the favor of the author or creator, if it exists at all. In many cases, it's a lot more of, you know, they'll create the book for you. They'll produce it, they'll, you know, and essentially they'll hand over files for your, your finished book. They'll help you get it into distribution. In that case, you know, there's some royalty splits there. But in many cases you're also free to go off and do what you want with those files. Sell it direct, do whatever, which nets you back 100% profit while still retaining all the rights. So having flexibility and creativity when they're, when they're sort of creating those financial models, I think has really helped people as well.
Lauren: Yeah, absolutely.
[24:03] – Determining if Hybrid Publishing is Right for You
Matt: The next thing we'll talk about is how do you know if, if hybrid publishing is right for you?
Lauren: Which is, I think, a very important question. Because I think that it's something that can sound very attractive to a lot of people, but that doesn't necessarily mean that it's the right fit for you. So I think that as we've already said, there is something, like there is a cost to it.
Matt: Yup.
Lauren: So right away first and foremost if you are trying to bring your book to market with a shoestring budget, this is not a solution for you.
Matt: Probably not. Correct.
Lauren: You're unlikely to find a reputable good faith hybrid publisher that is not going to cost you at least some money upfront.
Matt: For sure. Absolutely. Now what, what that cost ends up being. It does vary somewhat widely. So again, you have to – you know, we'll talk about some of those things to look for. But what are some of the things that would tell somebody like, this is probably the right thing for me?
Lauren: I think if you're... if you have more, more budget than you do time. Because this is absolutely... Even if you are doing the self-publishing route and you are putting together a team of people that are going to do all these services for you.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: There is still time involved in researching different freelancers and –
Matt: Yup.
Lauren: – hammering out the contract with them, and managing all of those –
Matt: A lot of time.
Lauren: – different – yeah. That's, you know, that's not saving you that much time. All that is, is, is giving you access to expertise. So this is a situation that is much more it's out of your hands to the extent that you want it to be. It's a one time contract. And then they take care of the rest.
Matt: To the extent that you want it to be.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: Yeah, let's be clear. In most cases, you still maintain most if not all creative control.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: Which is also the beauty of it, right? Versus traditional. So with hybrid we talked about you get that team of, of people, of professionals that are going to help you with the editing and the design and distribution and sales and marketing, but you still retain all of that control or most of it. Whereas with traditional, those things are going to happen also, to a degree, but you lose almost all creative control.
Lauren: Yeah.
Matt: So.
Lauren: I was talking about this with a couple of my friends recently, and we were talking about how a lot of traditional, a lot of traditionally published authors, there's almost always friction at the point where their cover design comes in. Because there's always, there's always a point where it's like the author and the agent had something in mind for the cover that they wanted.
Matt: The author definitely did.
Lauren: And, and they go back and forth with the editor, and the, the editor is the liaison between the creative team and the author and trying to hammer that out.
Matt: Well don’t forget the sales team.
Lauren: Well, and that's what I was gonna say –
Matt: The sales team I think ultimately has – yeah.
Lauren: And then even if there is a bunch of back and forth between – the sales team can still then come in and be like, we're not doing any of this –
Matt: Veto, yeah.
Lauren: – this is what we're –
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: – doing instead. And that will just blow the authors’ minds. As was like, what do you mean three other people can come in and say –
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: – no to this cover?
Matt: And in some cases that's okay. Again, we're not trying to take a big old dump on traditional publishing. You know, most of them have a formula. They've sold a lot of books.
Lauren: Yeah in that case I –
Matt: In many cases they, they kind of know what they're doing.
Lauren: Yeah.
Matt: To a degree. But, you know, again, a lot - these days, a lot of people, they've got a lot invested in their book and their project. You have more flexibility and freedom with things like hybrid publishing, self-publishing, whatever that might be. So, you know, if you are one of those creators or authors that's very much hands on, that very much wants to retain creative control and feels like a lot of that is, you know, very detrimental to your book. You know, those are just things to, to, to keep in mind.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: Back on the idea of, you know, whether or not hybrid publishing is right for you. I agree, I think that, you know, if you've got more money than time, it's a no brainer.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: Find a reputable hybrid publisher to work with, period. You're not managing a bunch of different freelancers on your own, you’re just paying one person. They're getting it done to your specs, the way that you want it, and move on. You know, if you have a preference for... you know, again, you want this project to go to market in a very certain specific type of way. That's obviously going to take some more extra time on your part. And when you could sort of farm that out, right, to somebody else that you, that you trust. And again, you have more money than you have time. Like to me that, that's a no brainer.
Lauren: I think, and also like to that point, what was that like, absolutely gorgeous book that, that you found last year?
Matt: Oh, Paul Millerd’s. It's the, the The Pathless Path.
Lauren: Yes. It was a beautiful linen wrapped book, but it came with a it came in a sleeve and it had all this, like, custom art, the packaging, everything about it.
Matt: Postcards and a notebook came with it.
Lauren: Yes. It was a very elaborate, beautiful –
Matt: Yes.
Lauren: – custom packaging.
Matt: And expensive.
Lauren: And expensive. That is just outside of the realm of possibility for a self-publishing print-on-demand company to do. So that is something that I think an individual author could not do that on their own. They would need, if you have this vision for bringing something –
Matt: Yes.
Lauren: – like that to market –
Matt: Yeah. And Paul, he worked with, he actually worked with, not so much a hybrid publisher, but they they consider themselves more of a book design company. They're called OtterPine. And basically, yeah, he worked with them because he had this vision of, you know, what he wanted to deliver as like the, you know, the top tier package for his book. And he's been very public. I think he paid between 70 and $80,000 for all of that. But again, beautifully done. Not something that would have happened with a traditional publisher at all.
Lauren: Right.
Matt: The fact that he was able to find, you know, this company that helped him design all of these things the way that he wanted it, they were able to source the production, you know, and get all of this done. Yeah that, that – again, somewhat of a hybrid model, although I don't know that they would consider themselves that, but 100% if you wanted to do something like that, which we're seeing more and more people do. Great. First of all, we need more stuff like that. But yeah the, this is the model that you need to chase. You need to find somebody that can, that can help you do that. You're not going to do all this on your own.
Lauren: No.
Matt: Like you said, there's no way.
Lauren: I don't think it would be possible.
Matt: It, it would be close to impossible. It's closer to impossible than it is –
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: Even us, with our knowledge and our connections in the industry and, you know, even connections with print facilities and things. Like, to get a project like that done, you really would have to work with somebody that that's what they do.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: You know? And again, if that's your goal and you have a very specific path to market, and the budget to do so... Absolutely.
Lauren: Yeah.
Matt: You know what I mean?
Lauren: Yeah. And then I think just even if, if you are somebody who is like depending – again, depending on your goals, if you are somebody who is very committed to the idea of bringing a book to market for XYZ reason, but you are not somebody with a lot of experience or familiarity with the publishing industry.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: You know, that is a question that we get all the time when we're at conferences and events and talking to people, is just I, I'm sold on the idea, but I don't even know where to start. And if you find yourself so overwhelmed by not knowing where to start – with, with the publishing part. You know how to write a book.
Matt: Right.
Lauren: You don't know what to do when you're done writing it. Sometimes a hybrid publisher can, can be the guidance that you need –
Matt: Most times, yeah.
Lauren: – to get you through that.
Matt: I mean, again, it's it's not just limited to treating them as a general contractor just to to farm out the stuff. Like, yeah, they really should be like your guide. They should, you know, be the one that's helping you, like shepherding you through this process. So yeah, if if your experience is very limited, you don't have the time to do a ton of research, especially maybe for your first book, working with a hybrid publisher is a great way to not only get the work done and get it done well, but also start to learn the ins and outs of the industry and maybe your next book you use one, maybe your next book you don't. But at least you're learning. You're gaining some valuable knowledge along the way. Most reputable hybrid publishers will also act as a guide. They will also kind of educate you on a lot of the things that are going into the production of that book. And then the distribution, the sales, and the marketing of that book as well.
Lauren: Yeah.
Matt: Yeah. And then I was going to mention, you know, whether or not hybrid publishing is right for you also depends on, you know, how much time and money you have to invest in the marketing and sales of your book. Now, this is also the one area that is the most gray when it comes to hybrid publishing. It tends to be the one where a lot of them catch a bad rap versus the ones that are actually able to deliver. Marketing itself is such a area of ambiguity at times for people, uncertainty, whatever you want to call it. Especially for authors and potentially creators. So there's a lot of room for unfulfilled promises, errors. You might pay for a hefty marketing package that includes a bunch of, like, Facebook ads and things like that. Where, to be frank, it's very easy to hide, you know, poor results and things, like algorithm and stuff like that. So, you know, that's where you're going to want to be careful. But again, if you don't have a lot of marketing experience and you've got some extra money and you've found a hybrid publisher that has a track record of being able to successfully market and sell books for their clients –
Lauren: In, in your niche.
Matt: Sure. In your niche for sure. Then you know that's also a big help for you.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: So.
Lauren: Absolutely, because I do – two things to that. One, absolutely agree. Because if it is, if you do find a one that has a marketing package that is available and it is a cookie cutter, one size fits all marketing package that's like, you know, we have this kind of results from Facebook ads... Okay, you're publishing a YA novel. I don't know how many 14 to 18 year old kids are on Facebook these days, but I'm guessing the number is not high. So I don't think that you're going to find your audience even if they have statistically have had success with this type of ad. That doesn't mean it's –
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: – gonna work for you. But also, I think it's important to recognize that hybrid publishing can be somewhat ala carte, where you can choose, like, very often choose between packages.
Matt: Some of them, yeah. Yeah.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: Yep.
Lauren: And that's something that you might want to look for as you're looking for a hybrid publisher is maybe you just want help with the pre-production part. Or maybe you, you, like you got that part down. But you need marketing and sales and distribution assistance or whatever it is.
Matt: Yeah, yeah.
Lauren: But before we get into the, the things to look for, I want to talk just a little bit about some of the, the trade offs that come with hybrid publishing.
Matt: Yeah. Of course.
Lauren: Yes. So obviously, as we've already said, there is upfront investment. So there is financial risk in that. You do have to have the capital ahead of time to be able to do that. You cannot just... you know, say I'm going to do it with $5 and a dream.
Matt: Right.
Lauren: Which you can with self-publishing. You can, you can try.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: You know, in theory, $5 in a dream and a free Lulu account could potentially get you a published book.
Matt: Maybe.
Lauren: I don't know what. I'd spend that $5 on.
Matt: Coffee.
Lauren: Monster.
Matt: Well, for you, yes. Yeah.
Lauren: But there is also, you know, there is some risk involved in that. Whether it's financial risk, whether it is reduced control over the production. Like we did say that there, you know, you do have a lot more control over your final product with a hybrid publisher than you would with traditional publishers.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: But you will have people that are pushing back against you making – unlike self-publishing.
Matt: Yeah. Although again, with a reputable one, I wouldn't call it pushing back. I'd call guidance. Right?
Lauren: Yes, I agree.
Matt: Like if I just come in there like a bull in a China shop. And I'm very adamant that the cover of my, you know, nonfiction, tech-oriented, AI, you know, book should have like some anime character on the front with a laptop and like, you know, some other cray – like, they need to push back.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: They need to educate me on, you know, covers sell books. Right? So push back, guidance, it’s a fine line sometimes. But you're right, yeah.
Lauren: Yes. Yeah. And then I think the other like really, really big one that's just not necessarily a trade off, but something that, that you definitely want to be very aware of before you get in any kind of contract with any hybrid publisher is the... The, not the promises, but making sure that you are not mistaking services provided for book sales and success.
[37:40] – Red Flags to Avoid When Researching Hybrid Publishers
Matt: Yes. And in fact, that also carries over into the next thing we're going to talk about, which is red flags.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: So one of the first red flags for me, for any hybrid publishing company or vanity press is if they make promises of success.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: Whether we'll get you, you know, as a bestseller or whatever, like be very leery of that. And in fact, I'll go on record as saying just walk away. Find another one. It's it's almost impossible to organically promise, you know, bestseller success. You know what I mean? Even gaming the Amazon system, while that's fairly easy, that's not necessarily an indicator of success if they make you an Amazon bestseller in some obscure category that nobody cares about, because achieving bestseller status in that obscure category means you sold twenty copies.
Lauren: Right.
Matt: Like who cares?
Lauren: Right.
Matt: So anybody that's guaranteeing you bestseller success or something like that, just walk away and go find somebody else. That's red flag number one.
Lauren: I think that the opportunity to guarantee anything immediate red flag. But I also think that there is a big difference – and, and people need to be cautious with this – with guarantees versus opportunities. If you are speaking to a hybrid publisher or any, anybody, if you're speaking to anybody, marketing services, anything like that, and they say to you we guarantee a New York Times profile for your book. That's not possible. They can't guarantee that.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: But if they say to you we have connections with editors at New York Times, and in the past we have been able to pitch successfully to them. So we will pitch this, we will pitch to them for a potential profile on your book. We cannot promise that it will be accepted, but we have the potential to do so. That's different.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: And that's what you're looking for. You're looking for a –
Matt: Well some people might be. Yeah.
Lauren: Maybe. Maybe. But like, you know.
Matt: Yeah. Some of the other red flags to look out for again are things that relate to money.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: In terms of sales. So what's the royalty split, if any? What does the profit model look like? You know, distribution sales, again what's the split there? What sales channels will they put the book in for you? Which ones are you responsible for? You know, make sure you're really reading the fine print there. But again, you want to find somebody that’s going to offer you the most flexibility possible. As well as, obviously the lowest, amount of money that they're going to take from your sales, if any. There are plenty of hybrid companies out there that pretty much operate off of, you know, 100% profit model to you. They're just turning over the files when they're done. And if you want files put into distribution, then you pay a split with them. But everything else is yours. I think those are probably the best. But nonetheless. Red flag would be, you know, them keeping a disproportionate amount of royalties on your book sales. Or, you know, things like they're controlling your files and where those files are distributed. Those are huge red flags.
Lauren: Yeah. Yeah. And hand in hand with that is rights ownership. If there is any kind of I mean, realistically, they should not have any access to your, to your book rights. You should retain 100% control over your rights.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: But if that is not the case, if there's any kind of situation where signing a contract with a publisher involves them having some control over your rights, make sure you understand what that is. What the terms of that are.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: What it includes like formats, international rights, movie or TV options, anything like that. How long the terms of that are? If it's something that's going to last for one year, five years, ten years, indefinitely, make sure you're very, very clear about the fine print on the rights management there.
Matt: Yeah. And if there's not, you know, necessarily a time box there. In other words, if they're claiming rights, but there's no like three year run out or five year run out, is there an author buyback clause and what is the time period on that? Even in traditional publishing there's often an author buyback clause where, you know, once your title goes to backlist and it sits for ten years, you're able to buy it back at a obviously discounted rate so that you own full rights, things like that. So 100% pay attention to rights. How much they want, if any. And then again, what's the time box there, if any? We talked about marketing and promotional support. So again, run from a guarantee. But think long and hard about partnerships. Track records where they've been able to establish, you know, solid sales on a particular channel or things like that. It doesn't mean that some of these hybrid publishers aren't good at selling books. We again, a guarantee, though, of a bestseller or something like that is just a, a huge red flag. It's a hard no. And then again, you know, similar to rights in general, you're going to sign some sort of contract or agreement. What does that really bind you to outside of rights or anything else? Is there anything else in that contract that's binding for you that could potentially put you in a weird situation later?
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: So. I think those are some of the red flags and things you need to look out for.
Lauren: Yeah, I, I definitely would just, you know. As always, do your homework, do your research. We did an episode earlier this year that I will link in the show notes that was on how to actually go about hiring freelancers for your book. And I think most of the things that we talked about in there would also carry over into this situation as well. You're just looking at a general hybrid publishing contract versus individual freelancer contracts. And that included things like, you know, vet, vet, the company's previous work. If it’s –
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: – not something that aligns with your brand or your brand values, if the aesthetic is not what you're looking for, if the genre is not what you're looking for, those are all important things to know. Go online and do research in author communities. Look for, for feedback from other people that have worked with these publishers before. Find out if, you know, if people have talked over and over and over again about how their service providers have failed to deliver content on time, like they've consistently said they'll get it back to you in five weeks and it takes eight or nine weeks, that's a problem.
Matt: I think –
Lauren: Like –
Matt: – that's the important one. And I think most importantly, you would treat them the same way, like I said, you would hire a general contractor –
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: – for a home remodeling job. So one of the first things you should ask them for is the name of some of their most recently published titles, right? And contact those authors.
Lauren: Yes.
Matt: And just say hey, I'm thinking about using such and such. What was your experience? You know, most of the time your peers and other authors, they're going to be fine with, you know, shooting you an email back and giving you an honest assessment of of that service or that company or whatever it was. But, you know, online communities are great, although sometimes they can be a bit misleading. You know, we know for a fact that people tend to primarily only talk about things online when they have a problem, not when something went super well.
Lauren: Right.
Matt: So you know, again, treat those cautiously, or with cautious optimism, if you will. But most importantly, any hybrid publisher worth their salt will give you references. They will give you the names of titles – If they're not already displayed on their website, by the way. Of, you know, their last couple of titles, it's probably fairly easy to find a contact for, for a couple of those authors and reach out to them. I wouldn't work with any hybrid publishing company without some referrals. Period.
Lauren: Agreed.
Matt: Yeah, everything else can be manufactured just like anything else in this world. I'm not buying anything these days just because the reviews on their site or some other site said it was like, I'm just not, you know what I mean? Like.
Lauren: Yup.
Matt: I need a referral from somebody I know.
Lauren: Yup.
Matt: Like, has anybody that I know in my circle used this brand, this company, whatever. Right? Like I might take a chance on a new Mexican restaurant in my neighborhood, because I just absolutely love Mexican food and I'm just going to go myself. But, you know, I'm not buying anything, especially a major service like hybrid publishing, just because, you know, a couple people in an online community said oh yeah, I heard they're pretty good, or whatever.
Lauren: Yup.
Matt: Yeah. Get some straight up word of mouth referrals, talk to people who've actually used them. Another red flag if they won't give you referrals. Say that's cool. Walk away.
Lauren: Absolutely.
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: Absolutely agree.
[46:57] – Episode Wrap Up
Lauren: But yeah, I mean, I think overall, as we've said throughout this episode, hybrid publishing can be a great solution if it is the right fit for you. We've talked about how to tell if it's the right fit for you. Even if you don't necessarily fall into those categories, it still might work for you. Just do your research, do your homework, know what your goals are ahead of time. Because depending on what your goals are, that might inform what you're looking for and –
Matt: Yeah.
Lauren: – what your priorities are when you're working with a service provider, whether it's a hybrid publisher or a freelancer. And, you know, do what you gotta do to bring your book to market. If this is, if this is the right way for you, great. Do it.
Matt: We didn't really talk about any hybrid publishers specifically on purpose. But we do have relationships with some. We have a partners page on Lulu where if you want to go and find a few hybrid publishers to reach out to and maybe start that vetting process, there are some on our partners page. If they're on our partners page, it's because generally or genuinely, we think they do a good job. We have some sort of relationship with them. So again, if you're not sure where to start and you think you might want to potentially explore a few hybrid publishers, that's a good place to start on our partners page. Another good place to start is Jane Friedman's Paths to Publishing PDF. There's a lot of good information there about hybrid publishing and hybrid publishers, so that's something we could link to also.
Lauren: Yeah, I'll put both of those in the show notes.
Matt: But otherwise yeah, we're super, you know, in support of hybrid publishing, it's just all about finding the right one. And finding one that works within your budget, if you have a budget for it. Yeah. So if you have any questions, reach out to us. But check the show notes for resources and our partners page. Do all the things, hit the like button, leave us a review. Good or bad. Even though I already said I don't care about reviews on my personal life, I do care about them for this podcast, so that'd be cool.
Lauren: I care about them not because I want everyone to be like, oh my God, we love you guys are the best. This podcast is the best podcast I've ever listened to. You don't have to leave that kind of review. I just want to know who's listening. Say hi. Let us, let us know you're listening. Let us know what episode you like, what you want more of, what you don't like, whatever it is.
Matt: Or whether or not you pronounce it niche or niche.
Lauren: Please do. Whatever, whatever it may be. This, this conversation can be a two way street.
Matt: Sure.
Lauren: You just have to leave a review or a comment or email us at podcast@lulu.com.
Matt: Yeah. Alright.
Lauren: Yeah. So do it. And then come back next week for another new episode.
Matt: Yes.
Lauren: And until then, thanks for listening.
Matt: Yep. I'm going to go eat lunch now.
Lauren: Thank God.
Matt: Later.